When Disputes Escalate, Professional Indemnity Might Help Defend You
A difficult client conversation can quickly become a formal complaint or claim.
October may feel a long way off. But if you employ people, it is closer than it looks.
Employment rights changes have already started to take effect, with more being phased in across 2026 and 2027. October 2026 is one of the key points employers should have on their radar, but it is part of a wider timetable.
FSB has already produced useful guidance on what the Employment Rights Act means for small businesses. This article looks at a different question:
If your responsibilities as an employer are changing, is your business insurance still keeping up?
This is not only an HR issue. It is a people-risk issue. If you have staff, customers, managers, working conditions, records and complaints procedures, you may also have insurance questions to think about.
The Employment Rights Act is being introduced in stages. Some changes are expected before October, while others will follow later.
The Government’s Business.gov.uk guidance says employment rights changes are being introduced gradually across 2026 and 2027. It also highlights areas employers may need to act on, including employment policies, holiday pay records and workplace procedures.
October 2026 is one of the dates to watch, with further employment law changes expected around workplace duties, trade union rights, tipping and harassment.
The wider reforms include several important areas for employers, such as:
For you, the concern may not just be what the law says. It may be how you manage the extra admin, records and risk in real life.
You may not have a large HR department, in-house legal support or spare management time. The work often lands with you, your directors or your managers, alongside everything else.
That makes October a sensible point to review your staff risks, workplace records and insurance arrangements.
You may already be trying to do the right thing.
You speak to staff informally. You deal with issues quickly. You make adjustments where you can. You rely on common sense.
But common sense does not always leave a paper trail.
If a complaint, injury, illness, grievance or tribunal claim arises later, the questions can become difficult:
This is where businesses can get caught out.
The issue is not always poor intent. Sometimes it is good intentions, stretched time and weak records.
Employers’ Liability insurance is usually a legal requirement if you employ staff.
It is designed to protect your business if an employee claims they were injured or became ill because of their work.
That could involve physical injury, workplace accidents, unsafe systems of work or illness linked to working conditions, depending on the circumstances and policy wording.
But Employers’ Liability is not a catch-all policy for every workplace problem.
It is not the same as HR advice. It is not employment law protection. It is not designed to cover every grievance, dismissal dispute or tribunal claim.
That distinction matters.
Some employment-related issues may sit closer to legal expenses, management liability, directors’ and officers’ cover or employment practices liability-style protection, depending on the policy.
So the question is not only:
“Do I have Employers’ Liability?”
It is also:
“Do I understand what my business is exposed to, and which parts of my insurance would respond?”
If your staff deal with customers, clients, suppliers, contractors or members of the public, your workplace risk is not limited to what happens between employees.
It can also include what happens while your employees are dealing with other people.
That may apply if you run a:
If your people are customer-facing, it is worth reviewing how you handle harassment, complaints, abusive behaviour, lone working, incident reporting and manager response.
This is not just about having a policy saved in a folder.
It is about whether your staff know what to do, your managers know how to respond, and your business can show what action was taken.
October is a good time to review the wider protection around your business.
This can help protect your business if an employee suffers injury or illness because of their work and brings a claim. It is a legal requirement, regardless of whether you are employing family, part-time, temporary, or volunteers. It can even apply when you employ certain types of contractors. Failure to comply with this legal requirement can result in fines and sanctions. Make sure you talk to your FSB Insurance Service broker before you take on any help.
This can help protect directors, officers and senior decision-makers personally if a claim is made against them for certain decisions taken while managing the business. Employment decisions, health and safety responsibilities, governance, finance and workplace procedures can all create personal exposure.
D&O is not compulsory, but it can provide valuable support with defence costs, compensation or investigations, subject to the policy terms.
Check out our blog Why Directors’ and Officers’ Insurance Matters
Six checks to make before October
Has your workforce changed since your last insurance review?
Think about:
Different working arrangements can create different legal and insurance questions.
If you have grown, changed opening hours, added services or taken on extra help, your insurance should reflect that.
Check whether your policy information is still accurate.
Look at:
Small changes can matter. A business that looked simple two years ago may now have a different risk profile.
If your staff deal with customers, clients, suppliers or the public, review your procedures.
Ask yourself:
This is especially important if your staff work alone, work late, visit client sites or deal with difficult customer situations.
Do you have legal expenses cover?
If so, do you know what it includes?
Check whether it offers support for:
Also, check the conditions. Some policies may require you to call a legal advice line before taking certain steps.
That detail can make a difference.
Employment decisions are often made by directors, owners or managers.
That could include hiring, dismissal, redundancy, disciplinary action, performance management, health and safety decisions or how complaints are handled.
If a decision is challenged, it may create pressure not just on the business but on the people running it.
That is why management liability or directors’ and officers’ cover may be worth discussing as part of a wider review.
Good records can make a major difference.
Before October, check whether you have clear records of:
You do not need to turn your business into a legal department. But if something is challenged months later, you need to be able to show what happened.
You do not need to start from scratch. There are free resources that can help you gather the information an insurance broker may ask for when reviewing your cover.
These tools do not replace tailored insurance advice, but they can help you prepare for a more useful conversation.
The Government’s employment changes hub can help you understand which workplace changes may affect your business in 2026 and 2027.
Link: New employment rights: Guidance for businesses and workers
Useful for spotting whether your employment duties, record keeping or staff procedures have changed since your last insurance review.
HSE has guidance on Employers’ Liability compulsory insurance, including when employers may need cover and what the legal requirement means.
Link: Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969 – HSE
Insurance angle: useful for checking the basics before reviewing your Employers’ Liability arrangements.
The HSE risk assessment template can help you record workplace risks, who may be harmed and what controls are in place.
Link: Risk assessment: Template and examples – HSE
Insurance angle: useful evidence when reviewing employee injury, illness, lone working, manual work, premises or equipment risks.
HSE provides tools for managing work-related stress, including stress risk assessment materials.
Link: Tools and templates – HSE
Insurance angle: useful if your business has staff workload, absence, wellbeing or management-pressure risks that could overlap with Employers’ Liability or wider people-risk discussions.
The EHRC has a checklist and action plan for preventing sexual harassment at work.
Link: Employer 8-step guide: Preventing sexual harassment at work | EHRC
Insurance angle: useful for customer-facing businesses reviewing harassment, third-party behaviour, staff reporting routes and management response.
Acas provides free workplace templates, including letters, forms and policy documents.
Link: Templates | Acas
Insurance angle: useful for building a clearer paper trail around employment decisions, absence, complaints and workplace procedures, which may matter if a claim or dispute arises.
You may only think about insurance when renewal arrives.
But employment law changes, staff changes and working practice changes do not always wait for renewal dates.
If you have taken on staff, changed premises, added services, extended opening hours, moved into more customer-facing work or changed how managers handle staff issues, now is a sensible time to review your cover.
This is not about creating unnecessary alarm. It is about spotting gaps while there is still time to deal with them.
When a claim, complaint or dispute lands, it may be too late to discover that your records are thin, your policy details are out of date, or the cover you assumed you had does not work the way you thought.
October 2026 is not just a date for HR teams.
It is a reminder to check whether your legal duties, workplace records and insurance protection still line up.
FSB Insurance Service can help you review whether your business insurance still fits the way you work.
If you are an FSB member and would like a clear, practical review of your business insurance, call 020 3883 7976.
This content is for general information only and is not intended to provide advice or a personal recommendation. Insurance cover is subject to the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the policy. Always consider your individual circumstances and seek professional advice before arranging insurance. External websites are not under our control and we are not responsible for their content.
A difficult client conversation can quickly become a formal complaint or claim.
The Employment Rights Act 2025 may change the risk picture for SME directors.
Workplace stress can become a legal, people and insurance issue for small businesses.